16 May 2012 09:00

Little room for error in Facebook valuation

In an equity theme that I wrote a couple of weeks ago, I pointed out how Facebook might turn out to be a winner stock - in terms of providing a better return on investment relative to the market as a whole. This judgement was based on the company's business case and an expected valuation of $75 billion, which was based on the assumption that weak markets would quell investor demand and drive the price down. However, the latest news suggests that the IPO values the company at $96 billion. I think that this is over-optimistic, and that Facebook has misinterpreted market sentiment, as demand does not seem strong at the proposed valuation.

In my earlier article, I calculated that Facebook could return 17.2% annualised growth until Q1 2016 based on my expected valuation contraction and earnings growth slowdown, which was derived from the experience of Google shares. This model was based on an IPO valuation of $75 billion and near-perfect execution of its business plan. Using the current valuation of $96 billion, the potential annualised return falls to 9.7% over the same period, bringing the potential return closer to what you might expect by investing in an index such as the S&P 500.

This gives a very small margin for error, an due to the fact that there is a good chance the execution will not be completely flawless, the annualised return could turn out to be even less. A valuation of $96 billion is just too tight to justify the risk. As I have already indicated, a valuation of $75 billion makes more sense, and a valuation of $55-60 billion would be the ideal valuation, as identified by fellow TradingFloor contributor Matt Bolduc.

For more on this topic visit Tradingfloor

Post comment

Related debate

  • 1 week
  • 1 month
  • 1 Year
20 Sep
 
Godt vi får bremset udviklingen i landet - Jeg håber også DK bliver det sidste land med selvkørende ..
19
23 Sep
NETS-TEMP
Det her er en klassisk case, hvor kapitalfondene på for kort tid, har fået lov til at realisere en s..
17
21 Sep
GEN
12% af dette er Genmabs - de har trinvis stigende royalty gående fra 12% til 20%. Og hvis man tolker..
16
25 Sep
 
Professor Jesper Rangvid fra CBS kom fredag med en stor kritik af private danske aktionærer. Han har..
14
26 Sep
OMXC20CAP
Er der ikke en admin eller sådan noget der kan slette baronen? Magen til evnesvag person der er yder..
11
21 Sep
BAVA
  Betydningen af de reviderede data er nok begrænset omend de peger i den rigtige retning.   Når jeg..
11
23 Sep
ZEAL
Åhhh nej begynder du nu igen. Kan du ikke også lige smide et postulat omkring noget blodbad mandag s..
9
21 Sep
GEN
Stigning 25% op i forhold til sidste måned. Mon ikke vi skal over de 1150 idag. 1300 here we come.
9
26 Sep
OMXC20CAP
Mener du "over bord"!? 
8
26 Sep
 
Mogens Lykketoft har fået det meste ud af sin totale mangel af praktiske evner. Tænk at kunne leve h..
8

Majedie Asset Management Ltd : Form 8.3 - PREMIER FARNELL PLC

26/09/2016 15:47:44
FORM 8.3   PUBLIC OPENING POSITION DISCLOSURE/DEALING DISCLOSURE BY A PERSON WITH INTERESTS IN RELEVANT SECURITIES REPRESENTING 1% O..

OZ Management LP : Form 8.3 - London Stock Exchange Group Plc

26/09/2016 13:59:23
FORM 8.3 PUBLIC OPENING POSITION DISCLOSURE/DEALING DISCLOSURE BY A PERSON WITH INTERESTS IN RELEVANT SECURITIES REPRESENTING 1% OR MORE ..

Novae Group plc: Director/PDMR Shareholding

23/09/2016 15:40:16
1 Details of the person discharging managerial responsibilities/ person closely associated ("PCA") ..

Most read news

  • 24 hours
  • 48 hours
  • 1 week
1
Endoscopic improvements with filgotinib are consistent with clinical remission rates in patients with Crohn's disease
2
Bionor Pharma ASA : Primary insider notification - Gunnar Flåten
3
Bionor Pharma ASA : Primary inside Notification - Maja A. Sommerfelt
4
Wärtsilä to participate in research programme aimed at creating an ecosystem for autonomous marine transport
5
FAIVELEY TRANSPORT TO SUPPLY HVAC SYSTEMS FOR THE NEW GENERATION OF S-BAHN TRAINS IN BERLIN, GERMANY

Buy and sell signals

  • Trend
  • Moneymachine

Copyright Euroinvestor A/S 2016   Disclaimer and Terms of Use
Quote information is delivered by Interactive Data.
Data is delayed 15-20 minutes according to the distribution agreements set by the different exchanges.
 
26 September 2016 23:24:35
(UTC) Dublin, Edinburgh, Lisbon, London
Version: LiveBranchBuild_20160921.1 - EUROWEB7 - 2016-09-27 00:24:35 - 2016-09-26 23:24:35 - 1000 - Website: OKAY